2021

Madi Walker

2020

Peyton Brown

Top 16 at Miss Teen USA

2019

Eliza Minor

2018

Kaaviya Sambasivam

4th Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

2017

Kenzie Hansley

2016

Emily Wakeman

1st Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

2015

Jane Axhoj

2nd Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

2014

Pammy Peters

2013

Kelsey Barberio

2012

Kathryn Puryear

Top 16 at Miss Teen USA

2011

Vanessa McLelland

2010

Lauren Martz

2009

Scarlett Howell

2008

Julia Dalton

2nd Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

2007

Katie Coble

2nd Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

2006

Melissa Lingafelt

1st Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

2005

Nikkie Groat

2004

Elizabeth Carty

2003

Erin Hendricks

2002

Brittany Crews

2001

Erin O’Kelley

2000

Chelsea Cooley

1999

Stephanie Holt

1998

Lucy Parker

1997

Ali Burr

2nd Runner-Up at Miss Teen USA

1996

Tammy Ashton

1995

Meredith Jackson

1994

Valerie Beasley